The only thing hovering over this Cleveland Browns season is the big question about who the long-term solution at quarterback is. Regardless, that’s a tomorrow problem because today, the Browns are 6-4 and in the lead for the final Wild Card spot in the AFC playoff race.
Deshaun Watson has surprisingly been good enough that he may even be considered for an extension this offseason while Shedeur Sanders looked like he took a step forward in his development during his spot start a couple of weeks ago. With two first-round picks in the 2027 draft, it’s a fair assumption that GM Andrew Berry will find the next franchise QB next April, but one analyst recently shared an idea for an alternate solution at the position.
During a recent appearance on Afternoon Drive on 92.3 The Fan, analyst Joe DeLeone brought up New York Giants quarterback J.J. McCarthy as a potential trade target.
“The problem is that the performance of the team has been so good, I don’t think the rookie quarterback route should be on the table anymore. The quarterback class, it has had its ups and downs. I don’t think that your future starter is going to be available in the teens or later…Might I interest you in J.J. McCarthy, who looks pretty good right now?” DeLeone said.
"The problem is that the performance of the team has been so good, I don't think the rookie quarterback route should be on the table anymore… Might I interest you in J.J. McCarthy who looks pretty good right now?"
📞 @joedeleone w/ @NickWilsonSays and @NickPedone12 on if the… pic.twitter.com/RTZsr8wYTS
— 92.3 The Fan (@923TheFan) November 20, 2026
It’s a fair point. Football fans everywhere are starting to grow concerned with the state of college football in general due to their increasing inability to develop pro-ready NFL starters. This QB class was heralded as an all-timer, and with just a few weeks until the College Football Playoff, Oklahoma State quarterback Drew Mestemaker is the one who has surprisingly flown past Arch Manning, LaNorris Sellers, Sam Leavitt, Trinidad Chambliss, Dante Moore, and all the other prospects that had fans excited all summer.
C.J. Carr, Darian Mensah, and Austin Simmons’ have seen their stocks rise, but DeLeone is right in pointing out that Cleveland’s draft positioning won’t be good enough to find the franchise guy unless Andrew Berry wants to trade up. If they really like somebody, they have the artillery to go up and get him, but it’s fair to wonder if that’s the best use of resources at this point.
McCarthy is just as young as some of these prospects and looks to be improving. If none of the 2027 prospects jump out, why not take a shot on the former top-ten pick? He’d be far from the first highly-touted prospect to bounce around the NFL a few times before finally finding long-term success in an unforeseen spot.
NEXT: Browns Coach Admits One Win Was Personal For Deshaun Watson








