Thanks to two excellent NFL Draft classes in a row, Cleveland Browns general manager Andrew Berry has built a strong reputation. The Browns’ success this season has a lot to do with the selections Berry and his staff have made.
Almost all of the 17 picks have contributed in some way, and a few of them are emerging as the best players at their position in the entire league. But there is a lingering doubt about Berry, and it could determine his overall legacy with the Browns.
Cleveland is still searching for a franchise QB, and even with Deshaun Watson’s performance this year, it is believed that the Browns will choose a quarterback with one of their two first-round picks in the 2027 NFL Draft. Whether Berry is up to the task remains to be seen.
That one question looms over Berry’s 2027 draft plans, with analyst Ken Carman wondering if fans believe he will finally find the answer the Browns have long been searching for.
“I wanna know if people feel differently about Andrew Berry than they did three months ago. Do they trust Andrew Berry again? If they never trusted Andrew Berry, do they now trust Andrew Berry? Lance Zierlein had his top 10 rookies, four of the top 10 rookies are Cleveland Browns. You ain’t gonna win six games this year without your rookies contributing a little bit, and they’ve contributed a lot. Your second-year guys have contributed a lot. Do you fully trust Andrew Berry? Let me go a step further here: if they do intend on taking a quarterback in 2027, do you trust Andrew to make that pick?” Carman said.
“Do you fully trust Andrew Berry?”
“If they do intend on taking a quarterback in 2027 … do you trust Andrew to make that pick?”
➡️ @KenCarman asks @SportsBoyTony if the #Browns’ rookie class has changed how fans feel about Berry making the next big QB decision. pic.twitter.com/yolXmRLPHQ
— 92.3 The Fan (@923TheFan) November 20, 2026
Berry was hired by Cleveland during the 2020 offseason, when Baker Mayfield was the incumbent quarterback, selected with the No. 1 overall pick in 2018. Since then, Berry has chosen four quarterbacks in the NFL Draft, none earlier than the third round.
It should be noted that the Browns did not have a first-round pick in 2022, 2023, or 2024, having traded them away to acquire Watson from the Houston Texans. Considered one of the worst deals in NFL history, at least before this season, that move was overseen by Berry.
Dorian Thompson-Robinson was a fifth-round pick in 2023. In 2025, Dillon Gabriel was a third-round pick, and Shedeur Sanders was taken in the fifth round. Last year, Taylen Green was a sixth-round choice.
Thompson-Robinson is no longer in the league, Gabriel and Sanders seem destined for careers as backups (with the Browns or somewhere else), and Green has yet to be active for a game as a rookie. So, it is fair to wonder if Berry can properly evaluate the position.
Combine that with the fluctuating value of the incoming QB class, and it could be a much more difficult process than the Browns or the fans would want to believe.
NEXT: One Browns Rookie Is Hitting His Stride At The Perfect Time








