Contract years have a way of bringing out the best in NFL players. With a new deal on the line, every snap matters, and some players take a big step forward right when their team has to decide whether to pay them. That puts front offices in a tough spot. A breakout season is great for the present, but it also drives up the price for the future. The Browns are facing that exact situation with one of their most improved defenders.
Isaiah McGuire is playing the best football of his career at the perfect time for his next contract.
The Browns drafted McGuire in the 4th round, 126th overall, in 2023 out of Missouri. As a 4th-round pick, he signed a 4-year rookie deal, which means he is set to become an unrestricted free agent in March unless the Browns sign him to an extension first.
His production this season has made that decision much more complicated. McGuire has started all 10 games and already has a career-high 4 sacks, along with 27 tackles, 6 tackles for loss and 5 quarterback hits. He had just 5.5 sacks combined over his first 3 seasons.
He has also come through when the Browns needed him. Each of his 4 sacks came in a home win, against the Carolina Panthers, Pittsburgh Steelers, Baltimore Ravens and Houston Texans.
McGuire has an 11.3% pressure rate, 3rd among Browns defensive linemen and edge rushers with at least 100 pass rushes. That is well ahead of Jared Verse, whom the Browns acquired in the Myles Garrett trade.
That is what makes this decision difficult. Young edge rushers who can get after the quarterback are among the most expensive players in free agency. At 25, McGuire would draw plenty of interest on the open market if he keeps this up.
The Browns also have plenty of other financial decisions to make. Deshaun Watson’s contract will force a major call this offseason, and Verse’s 5th-year option, worth nearly $28 million, is also due this spring.
Andrew Berry does have options. He could work out an extension before free agency, which is often cheaper than letting a player test the market. The Browns also hold 11 picks in the 2027 draft and could try to get a replacement.
McGuire’s final 7 games will go a long way toward setting his price.
NEXT: Todd Monken Saw Something In Deshaun Watson That No One Else Did








