It seems that no matter which choice the Cleveland Browns make, some fans are going to be unhappy. The team is currently kicking around ideas about who will be the starting quarterback next season, and the race will likely come down to either Deshaun Watson or Shedeur Sanders.
While speaking on 92.3 The Fan, Myles Simmons said he understands why Watson is in the mix, but doesn’t want to hear about it, and he prefers Sanders as QB1 and said he can’t count on Watson to do anything.
“I understand Deshaun Watson is gonna be there. I understand they’re paying him either way. I just don’t want to see it. 2020 was his last good season. I don’t understand how you can possibly count on him to do anything. I’d much rather see Shedeur Sanders,” Simmons said.
"I understand Deshaun Watson is gonna be there. I understand they're paying him either way. I just don't want to see it. 2020 was his last good season. I don't understand how you can possibly count on him to do anything. I'd much rather see Shedeur Sanders."
📞@MylesASimmons… pic.twitter.com/Kmnma1k4H7
— 92.3 The Fan (@923TheFan) April 2, 2026
It has certainly been several years since Watson played at an elite level in the NFL. His time with the Browns has unfortunately been brief and plagued by controversy and injury. If he is truly healthy and ready to play, 2026 could be a fresh start.
There are many fans still upset about Watson’s massive contract and just how much money it is costing the Browns. Seeing Watson on the field could be a reminder of just how much Cleveland spent to get him.
Plus, they can’t trust that he will perform or stay healthy. Meanwhile, Sanders has shown that he wants to be a starting quarterback. He may need to grow, and he might struggle in his own ways, but he has the desire, the health, and the youth that can lead to a great career.
New head coach Todd Monken wants to immediately change the culture and success of his team. He will do that by any means necessary. This is the start of a new chapter for him, and it could be a new beginning for Watson, too.
If Monken ultimately decides that Watson will start in 2026, he needs to be prepared for a lot of pushback from fans and analysts who are ready to move beyond him.
It might end up being the right move, but it’ll be a controversial one.
NEXT: Insider Notes Quiet Increase In Andrew Berry's Role
