As the Cleveland Browns continue their search for a new head coach, one name continues to dominate the conversation among fans and media alike. John Harbaugh has quickly become one of the most popular fan options tied to the Browns following his dismissal from the Baltimore Ravens. His résumé, familiarity with the AFC North, and reputation as a steady leader make him an easy sell on the surface. However, not everyone is convinced he should be viewed as the obvious answer.
During a recent segment on ESPN Cleveland, longtime radio host Tony Rizzo pushed back on the growing enthusiasm surrounding Harbaugh. Rizzo questioned whether Harbaugh’s legacy is being inflated based on longevity rather than postseason results, particularly during the Lamar Jackson era. While acknowledging Harbaugh’s consistency and respect around the league, Rizzo pointed out that Baltimore never reached a Super Bowl despite having an MVP quarterback for nearly a decade.
“John Harbaugh couldn’t get Lamar Jackson to a Super Bowl in 8 years,” Rizzo said.
"John Harbaugh couldn't get Lamar Jackson to a Super Bowl in 8 years," – Rizz thinks people might be overrating Harbaugh just a bit.
Do you agree? pic.twitter.com/8BtYMxGJSZ
— ESPN Cleveland (@ESPNCleveland) January 8, 2026
Harbaugh’s Ravens teams were almost always competitive, routinely finishing near the top of the AFC North and making regular playoff appearances. That stability is something the Browns have lacked for much of their history, which is why the appeal is easy to understand.
At the same time, the Browns are at a different crossroads than Baltimore was for much of Harbaugh’s tenure. This is not simply a roster in need of maintenance. It is a team searching for direction, offensive identity, and long-term quarterback clarity.
Rizzo’s point was not that Harbaugh is a bad coach. Rather, it was that fans may be assuming his arrival would automatically elevate the Browns into contenders. History suggests that it is far from guaranteed. Coaching success is often context-driven, and what worked in Baltimore may not translate cleanly to Cleveland’s current situation.
As the Browns continue evaluating candidates, Harbaugh will remain part of the discussion. But conversations like this highlight why the process cannot be driven by name recognition alone. The Browns need a coach who aligns with where the roster is headed, not just where it has been.
NEXT: Insider Hints That Browns Could Make Big Deshaun Watson Move
