As the Cleveland Browns narrow their head coaching search, one key factor could determine whether Rams pass game coordinator Nate Scheelhaase emerges as the final choice: proving he is ready for the full weight of being an NFL head coach.
Scheelhaase, one of the youngest candidates in the search, has quickly gained traction inside league circles because of his offensive background and rapid rise through the coaching ranks. However, his age and limited experience leading an entire organization remain a central topic among decision makers.
During a recent appearance on 92.3 The Fan, Browns insider Mary Kay Cabot discussed why the team will be taking a closer look at how Scheelhaase handles himself during the interview process when they meet with him on Monday.
“I do think that they want to get in front of him and talk to him to make sure that because he is so young, that he can handle all the things that go along with being a head coach,” Cabot said.
"I do think that they want to get in front of him and talk to him to make sure that because he is so young, that he can handle all the things that go along with being a head coach."
🚨 @MaryKayCabot w/ @RuiterWrongFAN & @NickPedone12 on #Browns Scheelhaase/Udinski differentiator pic.twitter.com/QyRKJBJI5N
— 92.3 The Fan (@923TheFan) January 25, 2026
That distinction goes beyond drawing up plays or calling an offense.
The Browns are looking for someone who can command a locker room, manage veteran personalities, work closely with the front office, and serve as the public face of the franchise during both success and adversity. For a franchise that has endured years of instability, leadership presence and organizational command carry just as much weight as football strategy.
Scheelhaase has earned praise for his intelligence and preparation, and his work with the Rams’ passing game has put him firmly on the radar as part of the league’s next generation of offensive-minded coaches.
The Browns’ quarterback issue looms over any new coach coming to town.
Several reports have indicated that Cleveland’s unsettled situation under center has already caused some candidates to hesitate.
Grant Udinski, another young finalist, faces similar scrutiny about his age.
If either Udinski or Scheelhaase can convince the Browns that they are ready to lead grown professionals, command respect, and manage the chaos that often surrounds the franchise, their youth may ultimately be viewed as an advantage rather than a risk.
NEXT: Analyst Says Recent Browns Coaching Report Is 'Overblown'
